1 user in 100 fails to read what is clearly a subscription, you can also review/manage active subscriptions in your paypal account.
The checkout page, the confirmation email, the invoice, and the receipt all clearly indicate a yearly recurring subscription, there was an option for a 1 time payment you chose the subscription and that is what you got.
Words like "stealing" are not called for, its your lack of reading ability to blame here, we stole nothing,
that said, I have refunded your last payment in full and wish you the best in your future endeavors. Good day.